Tiananmen Square

On June 4th, 20 years ago, many brave people died for demanding that their voices be heard. They wanted reform, freedom, and democracy. I think that when someone takes a stand for freedom at the risk of their own lives, they not only bring honor upon themselves, but elevate all of us, as a species, and we should all be proud of them, our brothers and sisters in the human family. As a small tribute to them, I spent some time reading about, and pondering the events that took place during the weeks that culminated that night on Tiananmen square.

Two quotes in particular caught my attention:

"Whether you like or not, the events ensured 20 years of fast economic growth"
Beijing Netizen, Beijing

"June 4th was a time when a group of people sacrificed their lives for democracy. We need to remember their efforts"
Steve Chan, Hong Kong

It cannot be denied that a peaceful demonstration for freedom is an honorable action and stems from basic human rights -on this belief we should not waver. We must also consider that freedom has many dimensions; political freedom does no good if people are starving, or can't educate themselves. These too are basic building blocks of freedom. History shows that lack of stability is detrimental of economic growth, and economic growth is necessary to elevate people from poverty, to provide education, and raise standards of living. Thus, it could be argued that the violent repression of June 4th was necessary for the long-term wellfare of the people.

So the question is this: was the benefit of crushing a potential revolution enough to justify the taking of so many lives?

I suggest that before answering, you take a deep breath, close your eyes, and imagine yourself in a room large enough to contain all the mothers, fathers, children, and friends of all those who were killed -a very, very large room.

Now imagine you have to ask that question to them.